top of page

Cambridgeshire councils on LGR at 'science cities' debate

22 hours ago
10 min read

Image; Future Cities Forum's 'science cities and local government re-organisation' debate at the West Hub, Cambridge University
Image; Future Cities Forum's 'science cities and local government re-organisation' debate at the West Hub, Cambridge University

Future Cities Forum is releasing the first part of its report from its 'Science Cities' discussion event at West Hub Cambridge which took place last week with Cambridge County Council, South Cambridgeshire District Council, Cambridge University's Estates Division, Manchester Airports Group as well as engineers, architects and planners from David Lock Associates, Grimshaw, Jestico + Whiles, Ridge, Pilbrow and Partners, Scott Brownrigg, MICA, LDA Design and Sheppard Robson.


The discussion covered the set-back of the UK government's local government re-organisation, decisions on which have now been delayed twice, and the growth of world-class science city innovation districts.


Co-founder of Future Cities Forum, Heather Fearfield, read out the comments of the Leader of Cambridgeshire County Council, Cllr Lucy Nethsingha, to Cambridgeshire County Council's Cllr Edna Murphy highlighting the issues over financial planning and talent attraction that she felt the delay has affected. Cllr Nethsingha had stated:


“This is a bitter disappointment and once again shows we have a Government incapable of making decisions or following through on its own policies. Cambridgeshire and Peterborough were already stuck in ‘LGR limbo’ and to simply extend that further beggars belief.


"Continued uncertainty simply creates increased risks, prevents us from making long-term plans and all at a time when the demand for and the costs of providing council services are rising.


"In particular, the anxiety and uncertainty that this creates for the hard-working staff in the 7 councils in this area is intolerable.


"We risk being unable to retain and recruit good people, we risk being unable to plan financially over the longer term and we risk being forced into making more short-term procurement and contract decisions, all because this Government can’t get its act together."


Image: stairwell in the West Hub - designed by Jestico + Whiles
Image: stairwell in the West Hub - designed by Jestico + Whiles



Cllr Edna Murphy was asked to comment:


'I've been a county councillor for Girton, Dry Drayton and Barhill since 2021. I am actually the portfolio holder for children and young people, so I have statutory responsibilities around children in Cambridgeshire. And we are on our way to LGR like everyone else.


'So I think the background is that all the councils in Cambridgeshire and Peterborough put in proposals, were invited to, or really we all felt required to put in proposals for local government re-organisation according to criteria that the government put in place. And that work was, it's really intensive for all the senior officers in council. It's incredibly intensive work that goes on for probably too long.


'That head space of all the senior officers is not being used to troubleshoot, to do improvement measures, to take the service forward. There is also a cliff edge where the council stops to exist, ceases to exist and therefore any long term planning goes out the window. But then it's managing contracts that do go beyond that period of time. Can we do that and are we getting best planning?


'So it is a fantastic overlay of intense work. You put in a submission and then you don't know what those are and then you don't know what they are. So our Chief Executive directed that no further work would take place. It's quite clear that no further work would take place until and unless we had a decision which would then be able to respond to that. Either to take it forward or not if there was no decision.


'The difficulty is that although we've all put in proposals, we've put in different proposals. So we don't actually know what the decision is that's going to be required of us. It could be the proposal that we have worked on. It could be the proposal that City Council has worked on. It could be the proposal that East Council or that other councils have put in. We don't know what the decision is going to be. And so the level of uncertainty is really going, well if you imagine you're an officer, if we could do a hand-over agenda, there are many councillors, many roles in the council where there's only one person. And maybe they'll have an opportunity in another council and maybe they won't. And they just don't know and they can't plan their own lives.


'So while they were in the tunnel of hard work coming up to a decision, they were sort of mentally prepared for it. And then to have uncertainty like this is just very difficult to cope with. And not once, but twice. The first time we got no decision when all the results were read out in Parliament. And so Cambridgeshire and one other council in the country has had no decision. Whereas others have had a decision which has been challenged or accepted. So yes, we just don't know where we are. It's just the impact on the senior team and on planning is very, very hard.


On the current announcements over skills development - with the county aware that it has to keep up with training in tech skills and apprenticeships, Cllr Murphy said:


'One of the aspects of devolution is that there's more money, more power going through the mayor instead of to local councils. I mean I don't think it's better to go to the mayor rather than local councils. I personally prefer these powers and money to go to local councils. But the fact is there is more money for the county going through the command authority. And there is definitely more money for skills. In particular the overwhelming concern about needs. And my portfolio of children and young people particularly plays into that because we're concerned about stent and the rise in incidents, increased incidents of young people and children who need extra support. And they will need extra support in school but also in work and to find work.


'So yes there is more money. I would say there's also a proposal to do curriculum changes in order to make the 14-16 curriculum more reflective of more vocational options and more reflective of the local economy. That said I really feel for schools because they're underfunded in Cambridgeshire as a starting point. The SEND reforms require a kind of step forward that frankly is incredibly, well shall we say high risk and very difficult. The local government reorganisation timetable is the same as the SEND reforms. That is not going to be helpful. And to add curriculum review on top of that I think is going to be an ask that is going to be very, very difficult to deliver. And without things like an effective transport system, that's one of the things that most affects children, young people, young adults, well and everybody, but especially young people where there's an instance growing up of isolation and loneliness. The image of a lonely person changing out is a young person.


'I think the concern that probably all the councillors share here is that development happens at the same time. And we would prefer infrastructure first. There's got to be, rather than we grow in one population here and then we realise they don't have a doctor and they don't have school and you know the transport problem. You know we need to move more holistically and provide facilities and services ahead if not at the centre.'



Image: Future Cities Forum at the West Hub
Image: Future Cities Forum at the West Hub


Leader of South Cambridgeshire District Council, Cllr Bridget Smith, was asked to comment on the delay to local re-organisation and the water crisis which is potentially a threat to the planning programme of house building:


'So if I speak with my national hat on because I think a couple of people aren't as up to speed on LGR as I am because we know the detail and normal people don't. So local government organisation, actually it was the last government who first introduced the idea of it so it was Michael Gove. When it was first mooted it was, Jim McMahon was the local government minister at the time and he is absolutely committed to the unitarisation of all councils across England and an awful lot of them are already unitary councils.


'There's not that many places where you still have two districts and county councils so that was him driving that. He then lost his job and his job was taken over by Stephen Reid who was a very different kettle of fish. Jim McMahon was a councillor in Oldham and I think he's a nice chap and understands local government even though I don't agree with his push to unitarisation but we're going to get it so we're going to do it well. Stephen Reid came in and had a different view on how the decision making over these business cases that we'd all submitted should be made. So he then lost his job and Angela Rayner came back in as Secretary of State and Jim McMahon came back in as local government minister. When they looked at the decisions that had been made they felt that, and we've said this publicly, they could not confidently stand up and own all of those decisions. What had happened in the meantime was that a whole load of judicial reviews had been lodged primarily by reformed councils but Oxfordshire is in a dead run, I think they've also lodged a judicial review.


'So government do not like losing for legal challenge and when they looked at these they weren't confident except the five. When the five they signed off two weeks ago and they went ahead and they were the ones that were uncontested, intended I think on the whole to be either single county or just two within a county. All the rest of them they said they were going to spend the six week recess while we all had conferences, they were going to be not reviewing the decisions that had been made but looking at those business cases that had been submitted and looking at what decisions they would make. And I do think that's what they've done. Now the last meeting I had with them, Thursday before last, they said they will be making all these decisions by the new year. I expect most of them to come by Christmas, I think they said by the new year has been so often overrunning government. And they said there is no reason to think that those two areas where no decisions have been made would be last, they rather implied actually they might make decisions on a kind of regional basis. So I'm kind of expecting a kind of East of England announcement but that's my interpretation of what they're saying. So what does this mean in real life?


'It means that there will be no new unitary council elections next May. Even the five places they agree with the decisions of the right ones, they will not have their elections until May 28th. So all the new unitary elections will be in May 28th. From my point of view, personal point of view, what a relief. I had elections this May, the idea of having more elections next May just filled me with abject horror. But, you know, a lot of places are now going to be in this position. So places, district councils that were due to have district elections next year will still have district elections next year. Everywhere will then have unitary elections in May 28th. And then there will be the strange year where the existing council and the shadow council run alongside each other getting ready for vesting day on the 1st of April 2029 when all the old councils cease to exist and the new councils become the legal entity. So as far as having this extra year, what does that mean?


'From my point of view, we're not doing what the county is doing. The county has said no more work. That's not what we're doing in South Cambridgeshire. We see this as an opportunity to do a load of work now that means that the transition into the new unitary will be much more seamless. So we have every expectation of being merged with Cambridgeshire City, possibly with East Cambridgeshire as well, probably most definitely with Cambridgeshire City. We both own our own housing stock so we will particularly look at opportunities to start merging that service. We already have shared planning, we already have shared waste, we have loads of other backroom stuff that's already shared. So we're using this as an opportunity for preparation so we're trying to look on it positively. The most important thing is that the new council is safe and legal and that references stuff that members can say, children's services, adult social care. The new unitaries will be the corporate parents, God knows how many, looked after children and they have to be safe. That's the number one priority. Additionally we want it to be seamless for our residents. We don't want you to know that anything's happened. Your bins will still be collected, your planning applications will still be dealt with and so on and so forth.


'So we've obviously submitted our local plan now and I'm really proud of this joint local plan. I think it is the greenest local plan that anyone in the country has ever submitted. I think it's really, really aspirational. I hope it's dealt with quickly. Unlike the previous one, it took nine or five years for the government's planning inspectors to sign off, which is why we then had to embark straight away on another one. Obviously the death code is the elephant in the room. So I was talking to Peter Freeman yesterday and we're still in a situation where his position as the chair has not been ratified yet. Hopefully that's going to happen soon. I hope it is Peter. I think he's done a fabulous job of getting to know everybody. He's a good convener, he's a good people person. We thought we had an outstanding chief exec who managed to jump ship before even starting the job and we thought we had a really good plan who managed to jump ship before starting the job. So if anybody's interested, there's a couple of vacancies there. I'm talking to the senior civil servant like before last who said if I had any suggestions for chief execs to let her know.


Image: Cambridge from the air - courtesy Webb Aviation
Image: Cambridge from the air - courtesy Webb Aviation


Cllr Smith was also asked about working with Cambridge Growth Conpany while maintaining its excellence in planning direction:


'So our joint planning service has won the award this year for the best planning service in the country, quite frankly. The trouble with government is we cannot move them away from thinking that the thing holding up growth is planning. No, it's not. We have 37,000 approvals as yet unbuilt. We're seeing major slowdowns. We're seeing some big players really reining back. We've seen somebody pulling out of North Stone when they've got permission to build a load of houses there. That's not down to planning. So the government needs to actually look at what the real factors are that are slowing things down a bit. The water that you mentioned, obviously we've got a sticking plaster solution to the water, but actually there needs to be something far more radical.


'Building reservoirs which aren't going to be built for another 15 years is not the solution. We need some solutions to deal with today's problems as much as with tomorrow's problems. So we had Bourne on hold with 6,500, 9,000 houses on hold because of no water. Eventually got a sticking plaster solution with the Environment Agency, but that could go ahead. But I don't see how we can get away without talking about desalination and so on. A long time ago someone said to me, Suffolk, Norfolk needs to have its water supplied by desalination plants and then the water they're currently using can come here. It seems a simple solution, but we have to have a government that's willing to invest a considerable amount of money in the need to solve it.'



 
 
 

Comments


Recent Posts
Archive

© FUTURE CITIES FORUM 2016 trademark of The Broadcast PR Business Ltd

bottom of page